Related
Despite being a beloved and iconic enfranchisement , theHarry Potterfilms have had some memorable scene that some fans actually really dislike . There are many instances in the motion-picture show that buff retrieve could have been handled a lot comfortably , even if the scenes did not follow the rule book to a football tee .
From the battle at the Departments of Mysteries inHarry Potter and the club of the Phoenixto the too - short Quidditch World Cup scene inGoblet of Fire , Redditors have listed the scenes from the movies that were the most unsatisfying .
Harry And Dumbledore At The End Of The Order Of The Phoenix
Dumbledore spends most of Harry ’s fifth year avoid him , excusing his pain sensation - inducing determination by saying it was all to avoid Voldemort ’s legilimency . However , the effect of his action are devastating , as Harry showcases at the end ofThe Order of the Phoenixwhen he finally lashes out at Dumbledore for isolating him .
Related:10 Hilarious Harry Potter - enliven Pick - Up crinkle , accord to Reddit
RedditorStanfan_meowman25commented that " that picture broke my heart to read … [Harry ] had every reason to scream and break thing … I really wanted to see that scene . " Given the unseasoned wizard ’s extensive psychic trauma and experienced loss , the pic should have admit Harry ’s rage to further show his emotional pain and how betrayed he really matte by Dumbledore , adding to their complicated dynamic .
Department Of Mysteries Battle
While the playscript delivered on the fifth installing ’s unexpressed promise with an entertaining , intense , and heartbreaking fight , its motion picture counterpart fail to dispatch the same mark . Redditordragracessssssaid they like hearing " saw more duel … I understand that it ’s only from Harry ’s POV , but wish we could ’ve pick up more . "
Dumbledore ’s Army ’s hard work and talents were not properly showcased in this choice opportunity , not to remark the omission of great moments like the babe - point Death Eater and Neville serve an out - of - commission Hermione . Given the significance this sequence had on Harry ’s life ( explaining his past , shatter his present tense , and narrowing his future , along with beingone of the most heartbreaking import ) , it merit more attention and screen time than it was throw .
Snape’s “DON’T CALL ME A COWARD!”
While Snape remains a contested character within the fandom , it ’s undeniable that he is one of the most complex and good characters in the series . But many of the nuanced details from his best scene in the books were omitted , such as his reveal at the end ofHarry Potter and the Half - Blood Prince .
Although the book execute the orgasm well with an emotionally - shoot down tantrum , the film give Snape a calmer , more subdued craze . Redditorveri_swthinks the films " want ferine Snape … I wanted to see more of a visceral reaction to being called a Sir Noel Pierce Coward . " Given Snape ’s already debated character , a fury - ridden and ego - driven reaction akin to the book would have furthered Snape ’s universe as a morally gray lineament with manyquotes that show he was a hero , butthat he was also a villain .
The Maze
The 4th installment in the series had a lot of potentiality to be epic . With thing like more schools , new characters , and interesting and terrific challenges , the celluloid had many great elements to form with . And while many were well - delivered there was one that was over - hype and under - used : the final Tri - Wizard Tournament challenge of the maze .
Related:10 Memes That Sum Up The chalice Of Fire
RedditorLingonberryPossible6disliked how it " lacked the clear and present peril of the first two trials by extinguish the monsters that were in the book . " Not only was the snarl a chip different than expected - made dependable and endlessly less sinister than the books - it was also not explored in as much profoundness and detail as all the hype toward the last challenge warranted .
Beauxbatons And Durmstrang Not Being CoEd
Potterheads who have only go out the movies will belike be under the impression that Viktor Krum ’s Drumstrang was a boys ' schooltime while Fleur Delacour ’s Beaxbatons was a girls ' one .
However , this could not be far from the truth and is one of thebiggest thingsThe Goblet of Firemovie leaves out . RedditorAubsedobs"hated every scene in [ Goblet of Fire ] that incriminate Beaxbatons was an all - girl school and Durmstrang was an all - boys school . " It ’s made canyon by books and other materials that both school are coed , and it ’s unsatisfying thatThe Goblet of Firedoesn’t portray that fact . rather , the film perpetuate certain sexist stereotypes through its segregation and depiction of the new bookman , disappointing fans with its misrepresentations .
Harry And Voldemort’s Flying Fight Scene
justly from his nascence , all the events in Harry Potter ’s life had been leading up to the moment where he could finally contend Voldemort as an equal . With all his Horcruxes destroy , this moment at last descend on - screen inHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 , but it was not everything that sports fan were carry .
The scene of Harry and Voldemort take flight in air together , hands all over each other ’s face , has been heavily criticized by fans . Redditormostlyclaudistated that they " detest it so much ! Always reminds me of Jim Carrey inThe Maskand unquestionably not in a honest manner . " This scene disappointed viewers because of its creepy and unsettling , not to bring up unnecessary , nature that took away from the two contender ' other scenes in the succession .
Harry Breaking The Elder Wand
While in the net photographic film , Harry is seen nonchalantly snapping the Elder Wand , in the book Harry actually recite Dumbledore he is going to put the all - powerful sceptre back where it follow from ( which arguably touch on to Dumbledore ’s tomb ) .
Related:9 Memes That Sum Up The Deathly Hallows Parts 1 & 2
Although the change in the cinema adaptations micturate gumption - given the worry the wand invites with its vaporous power - some fan were left disappointed with this scene . RedditorClimebheatmentioned that while they " agree with movie Harry doing it , I think the sheer [ guts ] that book Harry had to believe he would die undefeated just wins me over . " Having go through all that he did and finally prove his abilities as a wizard , Harry deserved the moment of subtle cockiness and to remain the true owner of the Deathly Hallows until the death .
Harry Saying Goodbye To Ron And Hermione
Even though there are plenty ofreasons why Hermione is actually Harry ’s good friend , Ron is as deserving of that form of address and has examine his deserving and loyalty countless time throughout the series . However , the films still put forward him as Hermione and Harry ’s sidekick , seen particularly in scenes where Harry bids the two bye-bye .
Such as in Deathly Hallows , where Redditorcndylsnoted that " Hermione puzzle a heartfelt clinch while Ron just stands awkwardly in the background signal . Absolutely hate this scene . " Ron deserve a lot more when it comes to his on - blind version , and slighting him by making him Harry ’s second thought thwarted fans of Ronald and also the Golden Trio ’s original book moral force .
Quidditch World Cup
Harry ’s first scene inThe Goblet of Fireinvolve him traveling with the Weasleys and co. to go see his first ever Quidditch World Cup . His acquaintance , Ron and the Twin especially , really hype up the event , and everyone ’s affinity - defining dress really adds to the anticipation of how capital this mate is reckon to be .
deplorably , it ’s over within mere moment , a disservice to many witness excited to see the compeer and book readers who were hoping to see some exciting tantrum translate on - projection screen . RedditorTrueloveis4upointed out how there was " all that build up up to a flash of light and the peer was over . " Given the anticipation that surrounded the event , a few extra minute render the genuine match would ’ve done wonders for the cinema .
Voldemort’s Death
Fans who record the account book will know that Tom Riddle does not plainly disintegrate into the aviation like someone fromInfinity War ’s blip . Instead , he dies like the deadly piece he is . But the film change this massive death scene entirely , not only disappointing fan but also changing the symbolic note value of his death .
Redditorhaggard_hobbitthought it " was really important imaging for his demise that he fell like a man and slumped over like a man because that ’s all he really was in the last - an angry , old , serviceman . " or else , the picture show ’s adaptation prove him dying an extraordinary last , show him to be something beyond a bitter and discriminatory deathly human beings , hence lessening the impingement and message of his dying .
Next:9 Best Fan Theories About Horcruxes , According To Reddit
