Related
Star Warscreator George Lucas entertained the idea of a major wrench involvingDarth Mauland General Grievous in the prequel geological era , but his estimate would have had major consequences and hurt the galaxy far , far away . In theStar Warscanon , Darth Maul ’s time as a Sith learner was bring to an goal by Obi - Wan Kenobi inStar warfare : Episode I - The Phantom Menace . He returned inStar Wars : The Clone Wars , and his story extend through the Dark Times of the Empire ’s sovereignty . It seems Lucas originally had other programme , however .
In a recent consultation , Star state of war : The Clone WarsandStar Wars Rebelswriter and executive producer Henry Gilroy revealedLucas originally planned a huge prequel villaintwist . He wanted Darth Maul to be fetch back as General Grievous , uncover to be alive via cybernetic enhancements as the being beneath the armor . evidently , this was an initial retainer during conversation with conception artists during the development ofStar Wars : Episode III - Revenge of the Sith , though Grievous terminate up becoming his own scoundrel . While it ’s surely a compelling musical theme on the surface , there would have been a negative impingement on theStar Warscontinuity going forward .
concern : Star Wars Is Debunking A Major " Balance Of The Force " Theory
Clone Wars And Rebels Would Have Lost Their Biggest Stories
The reappearance of Darth Maul was one of the big arcs inStar Wars : The Clone Wars , beginning at the ending of the quaternary season . Saved from expatriate and folly by his chum Savage Oppress and given fresh cybernetic legs by theNightsisters of Dathomir , Maul was reborn and at once set about planning his revenge against Obi - Wan Kenobi and Count Dooku , the new Sith apprentice whom Darth Sidious had substitute him with after his presumed death . Maul ’s part duringStar Wars : The Clone Warsculminated in the Siege of Mandalore in the popular and critically - acclaimed season 7 , where he escape detention during the chaos of lodge 66 , fleeing to form his newfangled crime syndicate , Crimson Dawn .
In timeline rescript , Maul next made a brief cameo inSolo : A Star Wars Story . His narrative really continues inStar Wars Rebels , where Maul became consumed by his compulsion for revenge against Obi - Wan Kenobi . His journey brought him to Tatooine where he was lastly hit by the expatriate Jedi Master tasked with catch over Luke Skywalker . These report are crucial toMaul ’s canon chronicle , and are very popular indeed with viewers - but could n’t have materialise if Maul became General Grievous , with a lineal persona inStar Wars : Episode III - Revenge of the Sith . That being said , the initial inspiration can be seen with Maul receive cybernetic leg to replace his at sea arm .
Maul Replacing Grievous Would Have Made Star Wars Feel Smaller
TheStar Warsgalaxy is a very grown topographic point feature innumerable reality , characters , and taradiddle . However , there have been prison term when the galax has mat needlessly small due to a modified centering on certain project . Luke Skywalker ’s complaints in the firstStar Warsmovie - in which he aver nothing ever happened on Tatooine - are now ludicrous regard how often audiences are constantly being drive to the desert cosmos . The same is true for lineament , with too muchfocus on the Skywalkers outside the mainStar Warssaga .
In that same vein , revealing General Grievous as a preexisting villain would have shrunk the orbit ofStar Warsas a whole . get Grievous as his own character made for a dynamic new villain to be introduce with a alone rack past and motivations ( though he did divvy up a solid hate for Obi - Wan Kenobi with Maul ) . Additionally , Grievous being a whole newfangled creation opened the threshold for Maul to make his return inStar warfare : The Clone Warsand beyond .
Related : Grogu Is The Mandalorian Chosen One - Star Wars Theory Explained
Maul As Grievous Would Have Made The Rule of Two Even More Confusing
The Rule of Two - that there should only ever be two Sith at any time - was established by Darth Bane a millenary ago to keep up the superpower of the Sith , but Maul as Grievous would have bent it too far . Palpatine was technically already breaking the Rule of Two , corrupting Count Dooku to the moody side and calling him as a Modern apprentice as soon as Darth Maul die out inStar war : Episode I - The Phantom Menace . He did the same with Anakin Skywalker , grooming him for years and ultimately having him replace Dooku . Even Dooku had agents skilled in the Force and/or lightsaber combat , such as General Grievous , Ventress , and Savage Oppress .
Maul give as Grievous would have made thing even foreign . Unless Maul ’s cybernetics as Grievous made him little more than a be weapon to be control , it would have been fox for Sidious to have his first and 2nd prentice serve him simultaneously . This would have been even odder given the clear parallel of latitude between the Maul / Grievous mash - up and Darth Vader , a Sith apprentice crippled and saved through cybernetics in the same way .
Palpatine’s Vader Plans Would Have Been Even More Complicated
The idea of Maul as Grievous would have also madeAnakin Skywalker ’s corruption into Darth Vadermore coordination compound . Killing Count Dooku at Palpatines ' urging was a major footstep in Anakin ’s corruption , making him unbalanced and more susceptible to the power of the dark side . However , the premiss would be that a Maul / Grievous hybrid would have had to be deal with as a 2nd Sith apprentice , either by Anakin himself or by Obi - Wan Kenobi who canonically dispatch Grievous on Utapau .
If Kenobi was the one to defeat Maul as a bionic man , there would have been some lose authority for Anakin inherit his raw purpose as Palpatine ’s apprentice . Conversely , Anakin kill Maul would have taken aside from Obi - Wan ’s established contention with both Maul and Grievous , regardless of whether Maul was the one beneath the armour or not . Likewise , General Grievous was always meant to be a precursor to Skywalker and his own cybernetics as Darth Vader . Adding a unavowed identity give away asDarth Maulto theStar Warscontinuity would have in all likelihood felt like a significant retread of Darth Vader revealing himself as Luke ’s father inThe Empire Strikes Back . Lucas always saidStar Warsshould be like poetry , but some rhymes do n’t work .
Next : Star Wars Finally continue A Forgotten Clone Wars Plot From 2013
