Related
The upcoming release of the video gameHogwarts Legacyis a timely reminder that even so many twelvemonth after the release ofHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows : Part 2 , there are still level to say and fans who want to engross themselves in this world again . And while they can live over the Wizarding World through rewatches , some buff started to observe that the principal characters have practice some refutable human action .
Redditors , in particular , have delineate some of the most gross of these , such as misleading betrayals and possible child endangerment . As it turns out , even in a universe likeHarry ceramicist , presuppose heroes are still capable of doing bad things .
Dumbledore Ignored Lupin’s Struggles
In some ways , Lupin ’s story is the distressing matter in theHarry Potterstories . He has clearly endured a great deal by the time that he comes to teach at Hogwarts , but he has a baronial spirit that can not be deny . However , it also has to be said that Dumbledore tends to ignore his conflict .
AsAggravating - Class419further abide by : “ He propose him a job only when Sirius broke out of Azkaban because he thought Lupin ’s knowledge about his former friend might aid them see him sooner . ” Though Dumbledore ’s actions are understandable , they are nevertheless an denotation of how misanthropical and remorseless he could be when it came to the well - being of Hogwarts as a whole .
Dumbledore And McGonagall Believed Sirius Could Betray Lily And James
Sirius is one of the good type to have emerged fromHarry Potter . He is , in fact , almost universally beloved among fans . However , he suffers a great trade in the movies , in particular , because everyone , including both McGonagall and Dumbledore , seems to believe he was actually up to of betraying his booster .
This itch many Redditors the incorrect way , includingajskgkjathrowaway , who writes : “ You ’re telling me dumbledore and mcgonagall thought sirius could ever sour him over to voldemort ? Please . adult secret plan hole . ” It is , to be trusted , not just a game muddle but also a betrayal of the part involved .
Dumbledore Constantly Endangers Children
Dumbledore might be one of the most powerful wizards inHarry Potter , but he is also one who is infamous for his sorry judgment when it comes to what he is willing to do with the students under his care .
Godumbledorkwrites , for example , that “ The fact that Dumbledore is n’t on trial for child endangerment ” is very perplexing to them . Indeed , there are numerous instances in both the pic and the books where the venerable old sorcerer seems to be almost disport by how much danger he subjects Harry and his friends to . While this is n’t always questioned in - universe , it is clearly still a sticking point for many fan .
Harry Not Learning Occlumency
Though he is the center of the story , there are many times whenHarry can be a jerk . In particular , his refusal to learn occlumency , because it was being instruct by Snape , was one of his most notorious lapses in judgment .
Redditorykickamoocow111writes eloquently of the consequences of this activeness : " This error let Voldemort to rig Harry into believing Sirius was in peril when in fact he was n’t . Harry ’s decision to go to the Department of Mysteries ended up being the determination that killed Sirius . ” In this case , Harry ’s pride and obstinance had annihilative consequences for both him and those that he loved and handle about .
Harry Using Unforgivable Curses
One of the worst thing Harry did was to use several unforgivable curses . Most notably , he used sectumsempra on Draco , without even full bonk what it would do . Dsjunior1388has this to say about this particular incident : “ using a spell you do n’t experience the resolution of is n’t too far off from trifle with a gun when you ’re not trusted if it ’s loaded or not . specially when it allege ‘ For enemies . ’ ”
While Harry might be the hero of this particular saga , the narrative nevertheless makes it clear that he is very uncoerced and able to do direful thing when he is own by his considerable temper .
Ron And Hermione Not Writing To Harry
Cedric Diggory ’s decease is one of the most traumatizing events in the moving-picture show , for both Harry and for the audience . It is thus all the more jarring that , in the summertime between that event and the next term , Harry is largely abandoned by his friends .
Lumos_vinoobserves : “ I know they were n’t allowed to because of the club and I think it was only a half a summer but I recollect being extremely upset / disappointed while reading . It really fix the tone for the sleep of theOOTPwith Harry feeling like a complete outsider the whole twelvemonth . ” For some , the actions of the characters , intelligible though they might be , are nevertheless a cause for cover concern , particularly since Harry is so miserable throughout decree of the Phoenix .
Ron Leaving Them In Woods
Though Ron might be one of the mostlikable of theHarry Pottercharacters , he has his moments when he shows a dark side to his personality . Under the influence of the Horcrux , for example , he get out Harry and Hermione behind .
Though his actions can be in part explicate by the locket , someReddit userscannot forgive him for his action : “ Okay , he was emphasize , athirst and the locket affected him more than any of the others , but he said he knew what he was getting in for , he knew the consequences , and just left them in the forest , Hermione crying . ” What ’s more , it is also worth pointing out that the Locket only exploited some insecurity and anger that was already present in Ron ’s mind .
Umbridge And The Centaurs
Dolores Umbridge is without a dubiety one of theevilest villains inHarry Potter . She is one of those multitude who seem to take genuine delight in causing others ' pain . Thus , it seems fitting at first glimpse that she gets kidnap by revengeful centaurs in the Forbidden Forest .
However , some Reddit users continue to be perplexed about the fact that Hermione lured Umbridge into the woods , even knowing the risk that the centaurs posed . Servalpur , for object lesson , writes : “ And Hermione f***ing have it off . She was the smartest witch of her age . She knew what was kick the bucket to happen , and she did it anyway . ” It is a notable moment in which even a hero is equal to of doing something that is , at best , morally confutative .
Dumbledore Keeping Harry In The Dark
From the very first ledger , it ’s clean-cut that Dumbledore has a firmer instruction and knowledge of what ’s pass away on than he is ever willing to let on . This pattern persists throughout the movies , and it ’s peculiarly egregious inOrder Of the Phoenix .
PigwidgeonPygmyPuffis particularly condemnatory of this storyline , stating : “ I hate so much ofOOTPwhen Dumbledore just ignores Harry and clear dumb conclusion about keeping the prophesy info from him . He was way more logical than that . ” While Dumbeldore might be one of the most dear character reference in the saga , he is also someone who is drive by his own sense of what is right and incorrect , one which sometimes be others very in a heartfelt way .
Hermione Trapping Rita Skeeter For An Unknown Amount Of Time
Rita Skeeter is one of the moreremarkably energetic side character inHarry Potter . She is also notoriously troublesome , and she causes Harry many headaches with her scurrilous “ reporting . ” However , while her captivity by Hermione seems like a meet punishment for her misbehavior , this is something that some Reddit user simply ca n’t let go of .
Redditorykickamoocow111argues : " … what Hermione did was illegal , and she decided to doll out her own sense of Department of Justice , not to observe blackmail Skeeter instead of turning her into sanction . What she did would probably get her 10 + years in prison . It was somewhat serious . ” While the picture show , and the books , do n’t want the audience to think too carefully about moments like these , clearly some Redditors are less willing to forgive even main characters .
NEXT : The Weasley Siblings , Ranked From Least To Most Successful
