Is Andor Better Than The Original Trilogy?

This article contains spoiler forAndorepisode 10.Andoris well one of the bestStar Warsprojects since the original trilogy . In 2012,Disney acquire Lucasfilm for $ 4.05 billion . It ’s an open arcanum that this new geological era has been mix forStar Wars , with the theatrical films in a constant State Department of flux and the subsequence trilogy criticized for coming to a dissatisfactory conclusion . The greatest success , however , has come in term of transmedia ; under Disney , Star Warshas boom into a true transmedia dealership , where the Disney+ television shows really do feel just as authoritative as the films themselves .

Tony Gilroy’sAndoris proving to be one of the most successful appearance to date , receiving popular and critical acclamation ; at time of committal to writing , it has a critic score of 92 per penny on review aggregate internet site Rotten Tomatoes , and an audience score of 85 per centime , suggesting critic and audience alike have been won over by the show . It ’s a unique project , several steps take from the mainStar Warssaga;Andorconsciously cuts down on Easter egg and fan - service , instead assure a tense story about the birth of the Rebel Alliance in which only one major character ( Genevieve O’Reilly ’s Mon Mothma ) even appears in Lucas ' films . Naturally , this is lead many to compareAndorto everything that ’s gone before , and to ask if this really is the bestStar Warsto date .

Related : Is That Character Secretly Princess Leia In Andor ? !

Andor Is One Of The Best Star Wars Projects Since The Original Trilogy

Andoris sure enough one of the bestStar Warsprojects since the original trilogy . The latest Disney+ idiot box series embrace the political imagery ofStar Warsin a way that has n’t been seen since the prequels , but it handles the political science with a deft skill that was sadly wanting in the like ofStar war : Episode I - The Phantom MenaceandStar Wars : Episode II - Attack of the Clones . Andorwears its politicson its sleeve , making its statements with an strange stage of hardiness , and the dialogue is sharp enough to pass viewers into even Senate machinations . Looking beyond Lucas ' time in charge of the franchise , Andorblows almost everything else from the Disney era out of the water . OnlyThe MandalorianandRogue One : A Star Wars Storycan compete , butAndoris easily written than either , and has much stronger character arcs .

Andor IS Better Than The Original Star Wars Trilogy In Some Ways

There are some ways in whichAndoris understandably well than even theStar Warsoriginal trilogy . The writing is much more advanced , and the dialogue is so much better than anything indite by George Lucas ; as gifted a visionary as he may be , dialog was never Lucas ' strong suit . Alec Guinness hated work out on the firstStar Warsfilm , complaining that the writing was " rubbish . " " George , you could type this * * * * , but you ca n’t say it , " Harrison Ford once snapped at Lucas during output of the original trilogy ; he later claimed he was joking , but the commentary rings uncomfortably true . The dividing line withAndoris marked , with dialogue work on so many unlike levels , and sequence 10 in particular featuring spine - cool speech communication from major histrion . It helps that the actors are understandably loving their parts , delight in the opportunities they ’re given by the script .

Andoris also much more sophisticated on a thematic level . Lucas always intendedStar Warsto suffice as something of a comment on American military exceptionalism ; theRebels are essentially terrorists , enliven by the Khmer Rouge . Andor , however , has taken this one step further , go for these themes to the age of Donald Trump . Luthen ’s speech communication inAndorepisode 10 is perhaps the most powerful in the history ofStar Wars , pass on an idea of what it really means to fight against the Empire in the Dark Times of Palpatine ’s reign .

Star Wars' Original Trilogy Could Never Have Been Like Andor

And yet , it must be note there ’s a sense in which this is compare apple to oranges . Lucas envisionedStar Warsas principally being aimed at children , and he wanted his story to be noted for its breakneck pace . This can even be ensure in the pattern for classicStar Warsships , with theRebel Alliance ’s X - Wingsinspired by Lucas ' beloved hot rods . In contrast , Andoris much more ripe , and it moves at a much slower speed , taking the clip to grow a inviolable sensory faculty of place and deeper characterization . Lucas and Gilroy are employing completely dissimilar approach to storytelling , and calculate their productions at dissimilar consultation , meaning the comparisons are n’t really bonnie .

Related : Andy Serkis ' Andor Twist Is Even Better Than You Think

Ultimately, Andor Isn’t Better Than The Original Trilogy (But Comes Close)

Ultimately , then , Andorisnt better than the original trilogy - although , to be fair , it hail close . There ’s a certain indefinable wonder to the original trilogy , a magic that flow out of every conniption . The themes of Bob Hope and redemption resound in almost every moment , base that really would n’t be appropriate atAndor ’s point in theStar Warstimeline .

The heroes of the original trilogy are archetypes , meaning they stomach larger than living , where Andor ’s characters are deliberately designed to palpate more like ordinary people struggling to outlive in a totalitarian government . In terms of the villains , Darth Vader is one of the most effective baddie in cinematic account , his report taking surprising twists as Lucas ' films continue . It ’s true that the plot of the original trilogy is nowhere well-nigh as complex asAndor , but that ’s really for the best , because it means the movies can be enjoyed whether a viewer is a five - year - quondam or 50 .

Andor Makes Star Wars' Original Trilogy Even Better

Star Warsfans love to play different stories against one another , saying which one they consider better . The beauty of transmedia storytelling , however , is that the discrete parts do not take to compete ; rather , they can complement . To take up fromLuthen ’s monologue inAndorepisode 10,Andoris the coltsfoot at Nox , telling the story of those who dream of the twenty-four hours . Such a story only derives its substance from viewers knowing day will indeed let on ; the torch will be passed from Luthen and Cassian Andor to Luke Skywalker and Leia Organa , champions of the light whose radiance will run off the darkness . Without theStar Warsoriginal trilogy , Andoris bleak and disturbing , the future in doubtfulness .

Tony Gilroy’sAndoris peculiarly impressive , though , in that it actually makes the original trilogy better . It collapse a sense of just how dark the galaxy really got , how much of agamble the Rebel Alliancereally seemed against the Empire . The themes and conception in bid in the firstStar Warsfilm in finical are given even more deepness and power . This is , of course , what all the best prequel stories do ; they abide on their own two feet , but add weight to the main history . It ’s a delight to seeStar Warspull this off so well .

newfangled episode ofAndorrelease on Wednesdays on Disney+ .