Related
With evenmore intelligence and Capital footageregardingThe Ballad of Songbirds and Snakesbeing recently discharge , The Hunger Gamesfranchise is yet again get to the forefront of daddy civilization , with the eagerly anticipated prequel only a year away . Luckily , fan still have enough metre to re - live the glory of the original series in the meantime and be prompt of their favourite and most - controversial characters , including the highly contested Peeta Mellark .
He Was Insufferable In The Movies
AlthoughThe Hunger Gamesremains one of the most popular and renowned adolescent book - to - blind adaptations , not everyone enjoyed the series entirely . Whether it was certain alternative made or the cast , there are still many things about the films that rub fans the wrong manner , and for Redditorittyxbitty , that was the entirety of Peeta .
Related:10 Memes That Perfectly Sum Up Gale Hawthorne
They had " disliked him from the book and … imagine maybe [ they ] would like him in the movie … but it just made it worse . " Not everyone will have the same opinion on dear characters , and with Peeta ’s many flaws ( whether it be his constantly spite personality or beloved for theatrics in the name of self - saving ) , it ’s not hard to see how a dislike for his book fictional character would translate into full disdain for the on - sieve depiction .
He Was Useless Beyond The Love Story
Despite being one of the fewbest adolescent movies that are n’t read-only memory - coms , The Hunger Gamesfilms still pore much more heavily on the Gale - Katniss - Peeta beloved triangle than the books . This was a shortcoming , not only in terminal figure of getting across Collins ' deeper political messages but also since their romance do as a point of contention against Peeta .
As observe by aReddit user , the plot " involve a lovemaking story and Peeta was the only way to achieve that . Outside of [ that ] he ’s essentially useless . " Had the serial explore his type beyond show Katniss a softer - side to the world and representing hope in the form of altruism and love , perhaps Peeta would have appealed to all the masses instead of being another lovestruck dystopian teen .
He Was Too Righteous
Peeta ’s continuous kindness , empathy , and nonjudgmental personality are delimitate and redeeming trait for his character , as well as reasons whyThe Hunger Gamescharacter would have a great friendship with Harry Potter . However , Peeta can be seen as too good to a error .
Redditorsekai-31noted that his over - righteousness made him seem like " he does n’t have a single bad os in his body [ and ] that ’s just not how people are . " While his unparalleled goodness and affectionateness made him remain firm out to Katniss and many fans , he seemed almost too respectable to be true as he get over every dark and maintained his pure heart even after the worst of context .
His Arc Was Resolved Too Easily
It is revealed that Peeta go away through extensive torture and harrowing hijacking during the events ofMockingjay , and many rooter conceive this important spark got swept under the wrong and was not properly break up — a precipitation for Peeta ’s character development . Redditorshowmaxtercommented on how " Collins contribute this love Triangulum an soft mode out [ since ] Peeta ’s electric discharge was solved too well … the highjacking just acted in his favour . "
Related:9 Memes That absolutely Sum Up Katniss Everdeen
Although Collins does drop some time detailing the depth of Peeta ’s agony and how deep - rooted the hijacking running game , this was the one electric discharge that could have append some unprecedented deepness and darkness to Peeta ’s character . Sadly , it gets resolved in a too - easy and too - simple way , with Katniss guide him back to the light and establishing their earnest love instead .
He Should’ve Died After The First Hunger Games
Although wide regard as one of thebest film about deadly world challenger , the first instalment ofThe Hunger Gamesended on a much more ( deceivingly ) optimistic feeling than the others , with both Katniss and Peeta miraculously making it out due to Katniss ' quick guile . However , some fan think Peeta ’s natural selection deflower his spark .
Redditorkitten451noted that there was " really no ground for Peeta to exist other than his kinship with Katniss , and I think it made the story a little too cliché . " While Peeta ’s survival was a primal point in the series that trigger off the flight of the eventual rising , it did take off from the potential of induce a aggrieve Katniss take up a much more personal score with the Capitol earlier on in the series . Plus , Peeta would ’ve died a martyr .
He Was A Burden
Peeta ’s on - filmdom portrayal made him seem much weaker than he was in the book , a large reason behind him being one ofThe Hunger Games ' Christian Bible eccentric who are betterthan their motion-picture show counterparts . However , some fans thought even his book persona was a onus .
Redditorarear3322commented that he was mostly " pamper throughout the entire serial [ but ] treated as some sort of zep or of Katniss Level grandness . " Despite his cherubic nature and helpful purpose , there ’s no doubtfulness that Peeta often attend as a hindrance for Katniss . Whether that was incline to his injury in their first games or his entire bow inMockingjay , he was constantly either in danger or a terror himself .
He Was Bland
Despite being one of the serial publication ' primal and more complex characters , Peeta Mellark is still seen by some fan as being two - dimensional and not very exciting , peculiarly in comparison to some other fan - favorite characters , like Finnick or Johanna .
RedditorCarmina__Gadelicastated that they " regain him smooth and [ are ] not a fan of him and Katniss as a duo either [ since ] they are mismatched . " Given Katniss ' passionate , noncompliant , and strong personality , Peeta ’s more subdued nature seems a lot more canonic and empty - husk in comparison , specially in the movies , which have far less enactment than the record book series .
He Was Manipulative And Selfish
One of the best affair aboutThe Hunger Gamesis how virtuously complex the characters are , prompting fans to take a deeper look into their own opinions on important matter , such as what it mean to be political , correct , and moral . Even Peeta , the games and series ' golden shaver , has his faults .
Related:10 ' What If ' Scenarios That Would Change Everything In The Hunger Games
The First Movie Decimated His Character
Although movie adaptations are by and large less favorable to their book generator , some films whole deflower a beloved character for fans , and that is whatThe hungriness Gamesappeared to do for Peeta Mellark . When it comes to the first cinema , Redditordanubeveinsnoted that " Peeta in this film is kind of a whiny , pathetic and creepy , " with them specifically stating how poorly the bread and cave scenes were adapt on - covert .
Rather than showcasing how monumental both moments were for Katniss ' life and her relationship with Peeta , viewers got an unimpressionable , half - hearted love confession that in no way encompasses how Peeta reinstalled Katniss ' forgotten hope and perseveration . Not to mention , his rock’n’roll disguise was one ofthe cringiest parts ofThe Hunger Games .
He Should’ve Been The Mockingjay
Katniss is render as a valorous and genuine character from the beginning , with her trenchant approach to the Games and honoring of Rue embodying the trait of the Mockingjay long before she took up the symbolisation . However , some fans cogitate Peeta was the better pick .
AReddit userstated that " Peeta is the MVP of the serial . He should ’ve been the real Mockingjay [ since ] he ’s altruistic , small , and good . Katniss is edgy and saturnine . " While Katniss ' malcontent , strong - willed , and dauntless nature made her the complete and necessary Mockingjay , Peeta ’s opposite and endearing qualities would have made him an fantabulous candidate for the mantle . Plus , it would ’ve been interesting to see how his ever - lively representation of hope , mildness , and a better world get along in the gamey - stakes rebellion .
Next : The Hunger Games Relationships As Taylor Swift Songs
