The Walking Dead
This article may turn back references / video recording to violence , abuse , and gore
The Walking Deadwill conclude after 11 season with its finish on November 20 , 2022 , marking the ending of the arc for several characters . Carol Peletier is the longest - pass character along with Daryl Dixon , having been part of the show right from the first time of year . Although she ’s a highly popular character , there are some viewers who have dissent legal opinion .
Redditors with unpopular notion have arguments over Carol ’s deserving order from her remorseless mental attitude toward multitude to her friendship with Daryl . With Carol ’s clip onscreen determine to end presently , it ’s worth check out why some Redditors have been unimpressed with her when the majority of the fanbase has take aim a liking to the character .
Carol Should Have Never Come Back From Her Banishment
Rick banished Carol from the radical after he ascertain she ’d kill two people at the prison house just because of the slight chance that they might spread out their malady . Redditorwolfiewoods12didn’t like Carol ’s afterwards victorious retort , tell that “ she did save the mathematical group at Terminus , but they just wrote that in to make [ viewers ] like her again . ”
Carol was responsible for for deliver the grouping from Terminus , which redeemed her in Rick ’s middle . This is largely go out as one of her finest moments , but the Redditor thinks it was shoehorn to make up for one ofCarol ’s most controversial decisions inThe Walking Dead . To be bonny , Carol ’s violent death of innocent people really did lay her in an antagonistic light source .
Carol And Daryl’s Friendship Isn’t That Great
Carol and Daryl developed an unlikely relationship that many considerthe best friendship inThe walk Dead . RedditorN - E - Bdoesn’t concur on this point , writing that there ’s “ nothing interesting about Carol and Daryl ’s kinship . It ’s being played up way too much . ”
The dyad has had a perfervid time in late season when Carol ’s induction - well-chosen personality has clashed with Daryl ’s . Still , the majority of viewers remain to see the two as an legal action - packed duo and true survivor , so every sign of dissension between them is generally conclude .
Carol Is A Liability To The Group
Carol has seldom given thoughtfulness to the consequences of her actions , which fans have care since it makes her something of a rebel . That does n’t mean everyone ’s sold on this aspect , with RedditorFlat_Jury_6510writing that “ she makes so many stunned mistakes and bad decisions that hurt others . ”
Carol has endanger the ilk of T - Dog , Morgan , and Connie , among others due to her reckless personality . But since not acquit in such a way would go against her character , fans let it slip and appreciate the bow that open up from Carol ’s actions .
Carol Should Be Killed Off
Killing off an original case is something thatThe Walking Deadfans do n’t take account . With so few left , it would n’t be the most democratic decision . But RedditorFoochie506thinks Carol should seize with teeth because the show has n’t “ had any major death in a recollective fourth dimension and her discharge is somewhat much consummate . ”
With Daryl , Maggie , Rick , and Michonne all set for their own twisting - offs , Carol does appear to be without much to do . This does n’t mean that many would desire her dead due to Carol ’s secure fanbase , although the Redditor makes a fair period that Carol ’s demise would have the ask wallop .
Carol Has Had No Development In Years
RedditorPatDubzzthinks that Carol “ should have been kill off year ago and her theatrical role became stale after Terminus . ” This is in reference to her revolving arcs where Carol seems too smooth to kill or make up one’s mind against it entirely to become a non - factor in the present engagement .
Of naturally , The Walking Deadfans keep to be entertain by her front , meaning the Redditor ’s ruling is of very few to debate her development to be stunt . It would have been interesting to see which part might have receive a pushing had Carol been kill off right smart back in the 5th time of year .
Carol Doesn’t Have Redeeming Qualities Anymore
With so much line of descent on their helping hand , there are certainthings the characters did inThe Walking Deadthat fans ca n’t get over , with RedditorVenus6123writing that it “ feels like they ’re all slowly ferment into shells of who they used to be – Carol is already too far proceed . ”
Carol has taken the life of people within her own group by having her own form of justification , along with scaring innocent characters like Sam Anderson to indirectly cause their deaths . Viewers do n’t usually dwell on this matter , though , since the characters who have died have n’t been as important as Carol .
T-Dog Should Have Lived Instead Of Carol
T - Dog ’s last is among themost cringe - worthyWalking Deadmomentsfor how brutal it was , having saved Carol ’s lifespan as his final act . Redditorclodogg15writes that “ it should have been Carol … it palpate like his death was overshadowed , and he did n’t deserve that . ”
Carol had disappeared for a small while , which stole focus from T - Dog ’s death . His forfeiture put Carol on the path to becoming the autonomous and inviolable soul she now is , so this really is a live take . The edition of Carol that fans have connected with would n’t have evolve had she died alternatively of T - Dog .
Carol’s Moping Doesn’t Make Her Sympathetic
RedditorKingHadez_isn’t a fan of how Carol is limn in recent times , writing that “ she used to be such a badass , but now she ’s just so sentimental and over - emotional . ” This certainly is an unpopular opinion since Carol has become this way after lose so many people .
Carol ’s depressive province has primarily come up about due to Henry ’s death , with the passing of her son pushing her over the boundary . The Redditor is fair in their assessment that it is a far cry from the tough Carol that witness saw halfway through the series , but most of the interview has understand why she ’s changed .
Carol Was Wrong To Eliminate Lizzie
Carol ’s slaying of Lizzie is mostly seen as a necessary evil since the youngster had murderous tendencies that take to her killing her own babe . RedditorKrammberrythinks Carol should n’t have eliminated Lizzie “ because she did n’t realise death ( and at such a young years ) – Carol postulate her out back andOld Yeller - ed her . ”
Carol putting down Lizzie is among the most split - jerk scenes inThe Walking Deadsince she had take the duty of the nestling . It ’s true that Lizzie was very immature , but Carol ’s decisiveness can also be understand because she want to protect baby Judith from Lizzie ’s potential violent disorder .
Carol’s Morality Issues Are Exhausting
RedditorToxicBanana69feels that follow Carol ’s story is a wearing problem because she keeps “ toss - flopping between being a merciless killer and not require to harm a rainfly . ” Carol has had various times when she ’s been saddled by the shock of need lives , only to be spurred back into activity .
The Walking Deadhas made Carol go through this cycle quite a few time , although the Redditor ’s primary beef is that she has a ruthless attitude when she decides to take life again . The fanbase has been centripetal to these change because there ’s usually a justification for Carol to feel hangdog and vice versa , but it ’s also understandable why some are over this recur practice .
NEXT:10 Characters Who Must come along In Rick & Michonne ’s Spinoff In The Walking Dead
